Episode Summary
In this episode of The Aging Well Firefighter, Roy takes you behind the scenes of his latest article published in Firefighter Nation: “Accountability Without Alienation: How Shame Undermines First Responder Fitness”.
Through a personal story about one of his first clients, “Tammy,” Roy shares how a tough lesson early in his coaching career reshaped his entire "approach to fitness and accountability. He connects that experience to the culture of fitness in the fire service, challenging “no excuses” rhetoric and fitness gatekeeping that too often alienate firefighters instead of supporting them.
This episode is a “director’s commentary” on the Firefighter Nation article (read it here), offering deeper insights, personal reflections, and a call to action for building a fire service fitness culture rooted in support, compassion, and accountability without shame.
Key Topics Covered
Why shame and “no excuses” rhetoric fail as motivators in fitness
The story of “Tammy” and the lesson that changed Roy’s coaching approach
The double standard between how we treat mental health vs. physical health in the fire service
The dangers of fitness gatekeeping and rigid “one right way” training philosophies
Why everyone’s path to fitness is different — and why that matters for readiness
A call to action for firefighters and leaders to build supportive, inclusive fitness cultures
Memorable Quotes
“Shaming people with extreme accountability doesn’t get them motivated. It makes them feel like failures.”
“Just like my client Tammy, a lot of firefighters already know when they’re struggling with fitness. They don’t need to be reminded… What they need is support.”
“My question is: why do we treat mental health with compassion but physical health with judgment? Why do we accept shame and gatekeeping in one area of well-being when we would never ever tolerate it in another?”
“Shame doesn’t build stronger firefighters. Support does.”
Call to Action
Read Roy’s full article on Firefighter Nation: “Accountability Without Alienation: How Shame Undermines First Responder Fitness.” [article link]
For a deeper dive, check out Roy’s related Substack article and podcast episode: “The Hidden Cost of Hardcore Coaching.” [article link | podcast link]
Share this episode with your crew and start a conversation about how your firehouse approaches fitness.
Got a story about fitness culture in your firehouse? Roy would love to hear it — reach out and share your experience.
Connect with Roy
🌐 All links in one place: www.roysmalley.us
📸 Instagram: @roysmalley.us
👍 Facebook: @roysmalley.us
💼 LinkedIn: roysmalley
Subscribe & Support
If you enjoyed this episode, don’t forget to subscribe to The Aging Well Firefighter on your favorite podcast platform. Leave a rating and review to help more first responders, families, and communities find the show.
